Parameter | Carbon-Reinforced (C/C) | Carbon-Ceramic (C/SiC) |
Ishicilelo esiyinhloko | Cishe i-carbon fiber matrix (eyenziwe/eyenziwe ngentambo) ehlanganiswe ku-carbon matrix. | Ithusi le-carbon + i-ceramic matrix noma i-carbon substrate enokhuni lwe-silicon-carbide ceramic coating/impregnation. |
I-typical manufacturing | Ukushisa okuphezulu kwe-carbonization/graphitization kwe-preforms ngezinqubo ze-CVI/PIP/CVI+CVD. Kunama-cure cycles amade kanye ne-graphitization eshisayo. | I-Polymer precursor noma i-CVI izindlela ezilandelwa ukufakwa kwe-silicon noma i-sintering ukuze kukhiqizwe i-SiC bonding. Ukucubungula okushisayo kodwa ngezakhi zofuzo ezihlukene. |
Microstructure & anisotropy | I-Strongly anisotropic — izici (ezishisayo, eziphakeme) zixhomeke ekwakhekeni kwefayibha. Ingaklanywa ukuze ibe nokuhamba kwezakhiwo/ amandla okukhomba. | Ngaphezulu kwe-isotropic kune-C/C builds (i-ceramic matrix ilungisa izici). I-microcracks iziphatha ngokwehlukile ngoba ingxenye ye-ceramic ilawula ukuziphatha kokuphuka. |
Iphuzu elijwayelekile | ~1.4–1.9 g/cm³ (kuncike ekwenziweni). Kulula kakhulu uma kuqhathaniswa nezinsimbi. | ~2.2–3.2 g/cm³ (kuncike ku-SiC okuqukethwe/ukuphuma). Kubhekelele kunezinhlelo eziningi ze-C/C kodwa kusenokukhanya kakhulu kunezinsimbi. |
Ukuncipha kwemithwalo ephathelene ne-steel | 40–70% lukhuni kunama-rotor ensimbi afanayo, kuye ngesisindo nokwakheka. | Ngokuvamile 30–60% lukhuni kunezinsimbi, kuye ngedizayini yomthwali kanye nediski. |
Ukudluliswa kokushisa | Kungaba phezulu kakhulu emkhakheni we-fiber (kusuka ekudluliseni ukushisa ngokushesha phakathi kwe-fiber) kodwa kube phansi uma kubhekwa i-cross-plane. Ukusebenza kuncike ekuqondeni. | I-Moderate-to-good njengoba i-ceramic ikhuluma kakhulu. Ama-SiC rotors ahlinzeka ngokuqina kokuhamba kwe-thickness kodwa kusenjalo kuncane kakhulu kune-C/C composite. |
Umthamo wokushisa / ukushisa okungaguquki | Ithuba eliphansi lokuphakama kanye nekhono lokugcina ukushisa eliphansi kunezinsimbi. Ukuphathwa kokushisa ngokushesha kungasiza ngokwakhiwa ngezindlela zokuhambisa. | Ukushisa okuphezulu okungaguquki kuno-C/C ngenxa yokuhlanganiswa kwe-ceramic. Kulungile ekumelaneni nasekusabalaliseni ukushisa ngaphandle kokushintsha kwesakhiwo. |
Ibanga lokushisa lokusebenza | Extremely wide — usable well above 1,000°C in racing environments. Ideal for extreme, repeatable heat cycles. | Kuhle — kuqine kuze kube ≈900–1,000°C. I-SiC matrix iyavikela ekushiseni nasekuphukeni okungcono kunezinsimbi. |
I-coefficient ye-friction | Idizayinelwe ukusebenza namaphedi aphezulu ashukumisayo anesisekelo se-carbon — ukucindezela kuhlelwe ukuba kube kuhle futhi kuphezulu ezingeni eliphezulu. Ukunciphisa ukushisa okuphansi futhi kudinga izinga lokushisa eliphezulu ukuze kufinyelelwe ekubambeni okuhle. | Ukuphazamiseka okuqinile ezingeni eliphezulu lokushisa. Kuvame ukuhlinzekwa nezinsimbi ezikhethekile zokushisa okuphezulu noma amaphakethe e-ceramic. Ukubamba okubandayo kusemkhawulweni, uma kuqhathaniswa nezinsimbi zensimbi. I-μ ethile incike ekuhlanganiseni amaphakethe nasezingeni lokushisa. |
Gqoka: iphadi vs irotor | Ukugqoka kwe-rotor kuphansi uma kuqhathaniswa nezinhlelo zokugijima eziklanyelwe ngenhloso, kodwa ama-pads ayizibhamu. Ama-rotor e-carbon adinga ama-pads e-carbon ahambisanayo ukuze aphile kahle. | Ukugqoka kweRotor ngokujwayelekile kuphansi. I-C/SiC ivamise ukuba ne-abrasi ephansi kumaphedi aphezulu kunezinye izixazululo zensimbi. |
Impact / brittleness | Iqiniso, elinokubekezelela umonakalo emgqeni we-fiber. Kungenzeka kube nokuhlukana noma ukuvuvukala ngaphansi kokushaywa okuqondile kodwa kuncane kakhulu ukuvuvukala kune-ceramic ehlanzekile. | Ngaphezulu kokuphuka kune-C/C ngaphansi kokuthintana kwamaphuzu. I-matrix ye-ceramic ingaphuka ngendlela ecatshangwayo lapho kuthintwa kanzima. |
Ukukhathala & ukujikeleza kokushisa | nxa kuhle kuklanywe (ukuhlanganiswa kwefayibha + ukwelashwa kwe-resin/graphite). | Kuhle kakhulu ukuhlala kokushisa, kodwa ama-ceramics angathuthukisa ama-microcracks ngaphansi kokushisa okukhulu — ukuklama nokulawulwa kwekhwalithi kubalulekile. |
Ukugqwala & ukuhoxiswa | I-carbon iyashisa ezishisayo. Njalo, lezi zikhala zidinga ukuvikelwa noma zisetshenziswa ezindaweni ezilawulwayo zokushisa. | I-SiC matrix iyavikela kahle ekushintsheni. Ngokuvamile, lokhu kuhlangabezana nokugqwala kahle kune-carbon engavuliwe ezimweni eziningi. |
Ukubuyiselwa / ukulungiseka | Ukulungisa kungaba nzima — izikhumbuzo ngokuvamile zidingeka uma ubuso buphukile. | Ukulimala kwe-ceramic kuvamise ukusho ubuthakathaka bezakhiwo kule ngxenye ye-rotor. Lokhu kuvamise ukuxazululwa ngokufaka esikhundleni. |
Ukuhlanganiswa kwephedi yokumisa okuhle kakhulu | Izakhiwo ezikhethekile ze-carbon-on-carbon noma izixazululo eziphezulu zokushisa eziklanyelwe ama-rotor e-C/C. | Izixazululo ezikhethekile eziphezulu zokushisa ezihambisana nezinsimbi noma ezikhaleni. Ukukhetha amabhuleki kubalulekile ukuze kuthuthukiswe ukusebenza nokuphila kwe-rotor. |
Cold-start & street usability | Iphutha elibandayo — izinga lokuphazamiseka eliphansi kakhulu ezingeni eliphansi. Alifanele ukuhamba nsuku zonke noma ukusetshenziswa kwemigwaqo ejwayelekile, ngaphandle kokushisa ngaphambi kokuhamba. | Ngcono kune-C/C kwezinye izakhiwo. Izinhlelo eziningi ze-C/SiC zenzelwe ukusetshenziswa emgwaqweni (isb. Porsche PCCB) kodwa zinezinye izivumelwano ezimbalwa. |
NVH & uthuli/izwi | High dust debris and characteristic noise at low temps. NVH is a tradeoff for boosted performance. | Ithuli eliphansi kunezinye izikhwama zokugijima ezithile ezisemathinini kodwa kusekhona ukungathuli/ukuhlanzeka okungafani nezilungiselelo zokumisa ezijwayelekile. |
Izindleko | Extremely high — generally the most expensive rotor option. | Kubiza kakhulu kodwa ngokuvamile kuncane kunezikhungo ze-C/C ezikhethekile. |
Izicelo ezivamile | Imidlalo yemoto ye-Formula, i-MotoGP, imiqhudelwano ye-pro endurance. | Izimoto eziphakeme, ama-superbike, ukugijima kokuhlola, izimoto ezisezingeni eliphezulu. |
Ukugcinwa & ukuhlolwa | Kudinga ukuhlolwa okukhethekile nokunakekelwa/ukugcinwa ngokucophelela. | Needs good inspection for microcracking and bonding integrity. |
Ukuncintisana okuhle | Ukuzinza okuphezulu kakhulu kokushisa, ukonga okukhulu kwemithwalo, nokusebenza okungabikezelwa uma kusetshenziswa amaphedi afanele nokunakekelwa. | Ithoni engcono yokuhamba, ukumelana okuphezulu nokuphuma, iqinile ekuphenduleni, futhi kancane ikhululekile ekusetshenzisweni okuxubile. |
Best for | Ukugijima ezingeni eliphezulu futhi ufuna ukusebenza okuphezulu kakhulu. Yiba nolwazi lokunakekela/ukugcinwa okuqinile. | Ukusebenza okuphezulu kakhulu ngokusebenzisa okuthile kokubili izinhlelo zokusebenza. |