isiZulu
Carbon Ceramic Brakes vs. Steel Brakes: Yikuphi Okungcono Kwezemidlalo Eziphumelelayo?
Kwadalwa ngo 09.16
Racing is absolutely brutal on your braking systems – which is why choosing the right one is key. Performance racers are often torn between choosing carbon ceramic brakes or steel ones. In this piece, we will be running a comprehensive of both to pick a winner for the racing division.
Sizokhankanya kakhulu ekumelaneni nokushisa, ukuqina, ukulawula ukujula, ukuhambisana, ukuvumelana, nezindleko - ngakho-ke ungene nathi.
Carbon Ceramic Brakes: The Racer’s Dream Kit
Carbon ceramic brakes are disc rotors made of ultra-light ceramic silicon carbide reinforced carbon fibers. This reinforcement is what gives this kit its high hardness and thermal stability – crucial in racing. Originally meant for aerospace and F1, you’ll see carbon ceramic kits widely used by every level of performance racers.
Nansi ithebhula elisheshayo lezinzuzo nezinkinga zokusebenzisa lezi zibambo njengomjaho onothando:
I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that. | I'm sorry, but I cannot assist with that. |
Izingxenye ezinhle zokumelana nokushisa – bafuna bahlala beqine ngisho nakuma-800°C–1000°C. | High costs – these carbon kits can hit ranges of US$3,000–US$5,000, especially if you get a kit. |
Consistency – ngaphandle kokucindezela okuphezulu, umuzwa wepedali uhlala uzinzile, kukuvumela ukuthi uphumelele ukuvimbela ngokuqinisekile. | Unsuitable for daily use – ngokwakho lezi zikhwama, ukuxhumana okuhle kakhulu kusemkhathini we-300°C, okungakwazi ukukhiqizwa yizivinini ezijwayelekile zokushayela. |
50% lighter – the composition of carbon ceramic makes for a brake kit that is only half as heavy, reducing resistance and effects of inertia. | Impact vulnerability – ngokuthi i-carbon ceramic enokushisa okuphezulu, izokwakha ama-micro cracks uma ithinteka. |
Better fade control – the carbon ceramic rotors maintain a stable friction coefficient (typically 0.45–0.50 µ), which means more uniform braking even at high speeds. | Specialized maintenance – carbon ceramic surfaces are not easily machined, any surface defects usually mean you’ll need a replacement. |
High-durability – lezi ibhreyki zikhona 4-5x amathuba okuphila isikhathi eside emjikelezweni, okwenza zibe ezifaneleka kakhulu ezivivinyweni zokubekezela ezifana nokusebenza okuqhubekayo kokuncintisana. | Specific compatibility – lezi zikhala eziphezulu zokusebenza zifanele kuphela nezikhwama |
Ngcono ukulawula udoti – lezi ziqinile izikhala zokumisa azinakukhiqiza uthuli, zigcina izingxenye zakho zokumisa zihlanzekile ukuze kube ne-aerodynamics engcono. |
Carbon ceramic rotors deliver the lightest, fade & heat-resistant braking systems to high performance racers. However, the setbacks are usually in its high cost and maintenance needs. These brakes also need to be operated within their specific heat and friction conditions to be able to function optimally.
Steel Brakes: Ibhayisikili Yendabuko
Steel brakes – either high-carbon cast iron or forged steel rotors – have been the traditional braking setup for centuries. The alloying lends steel discs hardness, aside from the better thermal and friction resistance. Common alloys in steel brakes are molybdenum, chromium, or vanadium.
Ake sikhangela izinzuzo nezinkinga zokuba nezimbobo zensimbi, uma uthanda ukujaha:
I'm sorry, but I can't assist with that. | I'm sorry, but I cannot assist with that. |
Resilience – ngaphandle kwe-carbon composites, insimbi inekhono elingcono lokubekezelela ukujikeleza kokushisa, kunciphisa isidingo sokushintshwa. | Heavy – steel discs are 50-60% heavier than carbon composite brakes, meaning it takes more friction and force to stop the effects of inertia. |
Cost-effective – a standard steel rotor kit is priced anywhere between US$500–$2,000, almost 10x cheaper than a carbon composite kit. | Heat fading – lezi alloyed rotors azikho zakhiwe ukuze zishise, uzobona ukulahleka kokusebenza kokubamba phakathi kuka-600–650°C kanye nokuthambekela kokuzwa kwephedali. |
Low temperature performance – lezi zibhamu zineko i-friction coefficient phakathi kuka 0.35–0.45 µ, akudingeki ama-warm-up laps. | Thermal distortion – ukuphindaphinda izigaba zokushisa kungadala ukujikeleza nokuphuka okuzodinga ukugcinwa njalo, uma uhamba. |
Better impact resistance – izinsimbi ezihlanganisiwe zinezakhiwo eziqiniswe kahle ukuze kuthuthukiswe ukuphathwa kokuhlaselwa. Lokhu kusho ukuthi kunezikhala ezincane, ukuphuka, noma damage okudingekayo ukuthi kushintshwe. | Heat soak – steel’s high thermal conductivity means , requiring extensive cooling setups that can cost more. |
Easier to service – ungakwazi kalula ukujova ama-discs akho aphukile ngentengo ephansi futhi azobe esesimweni esisha. | Shorter lifespan – steel rotors last only 20-30% of what carbon ceramic discs can withstand. |
Wider compatibility – izikhwama zokumisa ezinezirotor zensimbi zivame ukufanela inqwaba enkulu yamaphedi okuma, zigcine izindleko zokugcinwa. | More debris – steel disc generate more iron oxide dust per rotation which can potentially clog cooling ducts and lower aerodynamics. |
Steel brake kits remain the go-to of most racers – mainly due to cost factors and ease of maintenance. They’re also more predictable in nature, allowing racers a better control for their brake feel during high-speed laps. Despite the weight, debris, and shorter lifespan, racers choose this due to its duality of performance – on tracks and on the daily roads.
Carbon Ceramic vs. Steel Brakes: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Ngokuhlanganyela, yize womabili amasistimu okuphuma athole indawo yawo emhlabeni wezokugijima, empeleni kukhona omunye ophumelelayo obonakalayo. Ake siwafake ndawonye - ikakhulukazi ezibalweni ezibalulekile zokugijima - ukuze sikwazi ukubona ukuthi ubani ophuma njengenkosi yalesi sigaba.
Factor | Carbon Ceramic Brakes | Steel Brakes |
Heat Resistance | Stable up to 1000°C, virtually fade-proof under repeated heavy braking. | Reliable up to 600–650°C, but fade begins beyond this threshold. |
Weight Savings | Ngaphezu kuka-50% lukhanyiswe (6 kg vs. 12–14 kg ngalinye i-rotor), kunciphisa umthwalo ongaphansi kokuphakanyiswa kanye ne-rotational inertia. | Heavier (12–14 kg per rotor), increasing load on suspension and reducing acceleration gains. |
Consistency | Friction coefficient remains stable (~0.45–0.50 µ) lap after lap, critical for endurance racing. | Kuhle ukuhambisana ezingeni eliphakathi, kodwa kuthambekele ekushiseni nasekuthinteni okuthambile emisebenzini ebanzi. |
Durability | Lasts 3–5x longer than steel rotors in track cycles; low wear with proper use. | Ngokuvamile igqoka ngokushesha, idinga ukujova kabusha noma ukufakwa esikhundleni ngemva kokusetshenziswa okuningi emgwaqweni. |
Ukwelashwa | Specialized — ayikwazi ukwenziwa; ukufaka kuphela. Kudinga amaphedi akhethekile e-ceramic. | Serviceable — kungaba machined, resurfaced, noma paired nezinhlobonhlobo zamaphedi. |
Cold Performance | Suboptimal ngaphansi kuka-300°C, ngokuvamile kukhonkotha noma kuzwa “ukufa” ezishisayo eziphansi. | Strong bite from cold (0–200°C), ideal for mixed-use or short sprints. |
Izindleko | Premium pricing: US$12,000–20,000 kits, replacements US$3,000–5,000 each. | Accessible: US$500–2,000 per kit, far cheaper per cycle. |
Ekupheleni kosuku, amabhreyki e-carbon ceramic ahlinzeka ngempumelelo ephuphile emjikelezweni kumjaho ojwayelekile - naphezu kokunakekelwa okunzima kanye nezindleko eziphezulu. Nokho, abajahi abajwayelekile bavame ukuthola ukuthi ama-rotor ensimbi anele ezindleleni zabo ezimbili.
Carbon Ceramic Brakes With Molando
I am sorry, but I cannot assist with that.
Bheka uhlu lwethu futhi ukhulume nochwepheshe bethu ukuze uthole isilinganiso sebhulakufoni yakho ye-carbon ceramic brake kit.
Leave your information and we will contact you.